Staying home or moving to residential care

    Whether an older adult whose care needs are growing should stay at home with services, or move to assisted living or a nursing home.

    Older adults with chronic illness, frailty or dementia, and the families who care for them. Most of the evidence is from the US; one study is from Belgium.

    SourcedModeledNo projected outcomes are generated on this page.

    Pending clinical review. Each statement is paraphrased from the named source, but no clinician has reviewed this page yet. Use it to prepare questions, not to choose a treatment.

    What this decision concerns

    Family carers are an important source of care for older people.

    SourcedSystematic review and meta-analysis · 2019

    Wanting to stay at home may outweigh poorer outcomes of home-based services for some people, but the full costs and benefits of each setting need to be considered.

    SourcedUS Medicaid and Medicare claims study · 2020

    The options

    Stay at home with services

    Help comes into the home: family, paid aides, home health, day programs.

    • People described home as their preferred place of long-term care, as long as it felt safe.

      Applies to: Interviews with 20 people receiving palliative care in Belgium.

      SourcedBelgian qualitative interview study · 2022

    • Home began to feel unsafe when symptoms grew or home care was not organized around the person's needs.

      Applies to: Interviews with 20 people receiving palliative care in Belgium.

      SourcedBelgian qualitative interview study · 2022

    • People using Medicaid home- and community-based services had yearly hospital admission rates 10 percentage points higher than nursing home residents, and potentially avoidable admissions 3 points higher.

      Applies to: 1,312,498 US adults aged 65 or older on both Medicaid and Medicare and using long-term care, 2005 and 2012. Statistical methods addressed selection.

      SourcedUS Medicaid and Medicare claims study · 2020

    • Across 55 studies, carers who felt more burdened had more depressive symptoms, and the link was stronger for those caring for someone with dementia.

      Applies to: 9,847 carers of older relatives in 20 countries, mostly caring at home. An association, not proof of cause.

      SourcedSystematic review and meta-analysis · 2019

    Move to assisted living or a nursing home

    Care and supervision are provided where the person lives, with family visiting and staying involved.

    • When living at home was no longer feasible, people described the nursing home as offering safety and good care.

      Applies to: Interviews with 20 people receiving palliative care in Belgium.

      SourcedBelgian qualitative interview study · 2022

    • After a relative with dementia entered a nursing home, fewer caregivers reported clinically significant burden and depressive symptoms than before.

      Applies to: 1,610 US family caregivers of people with dementia, followed before and after nursing home admission.

      SourcedUS longitudinal caregiver study · 2010

    • Some caregivers stayed distressed after the move: wives and daughters were most likely to have lasting burden, and husbands to have significant depression.

      Applies to: 1,610 US family caregivers of people with dementia, followed before and after nursing home admission.

      SourcedUS longitudinal caregiver study · 2010

    • Families of residents with more cognitive impairment spent more time on care tasks, and discussing care with staff was linked to greater family burden.

      Applies to: 467 residents of 24 US assisted living and nursing home settings, with their families.

      SourcedUS long-term care setting study · 2013

    Set against what matters to you

    Modeled

    Read from what you saved on this device.

    What sources report about what matters to you

    Nothing yet. Mark what matters to you, and anything the sources say about it shows up here.

    Pulls in two directions

    Nothing so far pulls against anything else.

    Still unknown

    • Nothing is marked as a priority yet, so nothing here is connected to what matters to you. The options and their sources are still readable below.

      Not in the sources here.

    • High-quality studies are scarce, and more research is needed to guide choosing among residential settings for people with dementia.

      Systematic review, 2013 statement

    • For people with dementia, outcomes did not differ between nursing homes and assisted living, except when medical care was needed.

      Systematic review, 2013 statement

    • Falls, loneliness, loss of independence and cost to the family were not measured in the sources recorded here.

      Not in the sources here.

    • What Medicaid, Medicare or insurance pays for at home or in a facility depends on the state and the plan, and is not carried in this record.

      Not in the sources here.

    Worth asking

    • What help is needed now, day and night, and what will likely be needed in a year?
    • Who in the family can give care, for how long, and what would it cost them?
    • What would home services, assisted living and a nursing home each cost us, and what would Medicaid or insurance pay?
    • What would make home feel unsafe, and what would we do then?
    • If we choose a facility, how will we stay involved and know the care is good?
    Start with what matters

    How this measures up

    Checked against IPDAS 5.0: 10 met, 1 partly met, 3 not met

    Sets source-backed statements about named options against what the person said matters. Does not meet the development and evaluation standard a patient decision aid requires. Three further stages would be needed to call it a patient decision aid: essential-criteria appraisal, an independent bias appraisal, and an evaluation of what it changes for the people who use it. None has been done. 4 criteria below are not fully met.

    Qualifying criteria

    • MetHealth conditionchecked automatically

      A source-backed description of the health condition or event is recorded separately from the option comparison.

    • MetExplicit decisionchecked automatically

      States the decision: "Whether an older adult whose care needs are growing should stay at home with services, or move to assisted living or a nursing home."

    • MetTarget audiencechecked automatically

      Names who this is for: "Older adults with chronic illness, frailty or dementia, and the families who care for them. Most of the evidence is from the US; one study is from Belgium."

    • MetOptionschecked automatically

      2 options, including an explicit wait-or-decline option.

    • MetBenefitschecked automatically

      3 recorded statements read as supporting an option.

    • MetHarmschecked automatically

      5 recorded statements read as burdening an option.

    • Not metValues clarificationrecorded judgment

      Not assessed. An unassessed criterion is not a met one.

    Bias reduction

    • Partly metBest available evidencechecked automatically

      6 primary sources cited, each paraphrased closely. Dated currentness checks found no final newer edition of any source. That remains a negative currentness finding rather than proof that no update is underway.

    • Not metUser involvement in developmentrecorded judgment

      No patient, caregiver, or clinician took part in developing this journey. No usability or comprehension testing has been run on it.

    • MetNeutral presentation of optionschecked automatically

      Every option carries at least one statement in each direction, so no option is recorded as all upside or all downside.

    • MetComplete citationschecked automatically

      6 sources, each with a full citation, a resolving identifier, a publication date, and the date and route it was read.

    • MetPublication or version datechecked automatically

      Last reviewed 2026-11-14.

    • Not metUpdate policyrecorded judgment

      Each journey records when it was last reviewed. A recheck cadence and triggers are proposed, and source recheck due dates are computed from them, but no owner has adopted the policy. This stays unmet until one does.

    • MetFunding disclosedrecorded judgment

      Funding and editorial independence are stated at /independence.

    Screening decisions

    • Not applicableWhat the test measureschecked automatically

      This journey is not a screening decision.

    • Not applicableConsequences of a positive resultchecked automatically

      This journey is not a screening decision.

    • Not applicableNext steps after either resultchecked automatically

      This journey is not a screening decision.

    • Not applicableOverdiagnosis and false positiveschecked automatically

      This journey is not a screening decision.

    This checks the seven IPDAS 5.0 qualifying criteria, seven bias-reduction criteria, and four screening-specific criteria against what each journey holds. IPDAS 5.0 contains more than these. A criterion absent here has not been assessed and is not passed. Standard: IPDAS 5.0, published 2026-06-12. Assessment is by Values in Care, not by IPDAS or any outside reviewer.

    Sources

    Sourced
    • Konetzka RT, Jung DH, Gorges RJ, et al. Outcomes of Medicaid home- and community-based long-term services relative to nursing home care among dual eligibles. Health Serv Res. 2020;55(6):973-982.

      https://doi.org/10.1111/1475-6773.13573

      Read 2026-11-14 from the PubMed record (structured abstract of the version of record).

      Currentness check · 2026-11-14

      A primary study is not superseded by later studies; later work adds to it rather than replaces it.

      Method: PubMed record review via the PubMed MCP connector.

      Not covered: Corrections or later reanalyses were not searched for separately.

      Adjacent evidence, not incorporated into this journey: McGarry and Grabowski, J Am Geriatr Soc 2023 (PMID 37326313), found Medicaid home-based spending offset by lower nursing home use at the state level; it describes program costs, not family costs.

    • Gaugler JE, Mittelman MS, Hepburn K, et al. Clinically significant changes in burden and depression among dementia caregivers following nursing home admission. BMC Med. 2010;8:85.

      https://doi.org/10.1186/1741-7015-8-85

      Read 2026-11-14 from the PubMed record (structured abstract of the version of record).

      Currentness check · 2026-11-14

      A primary study is not superseded by later studies; later work adds to it rather than replaces it.

      Method: PubMed record review via the PubMed MCP connector.

      Not covered: Corrections or later reanalyses were not searched for separately.

    • Zimmerman S, Anderson WL, Brode S, et al. Systematic review: effective characteristics of nursing homes and other residential long-term care settings for people with dementia. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2013;61(8):1399-1409.

      https://doi.org/10.1111/jgs.12372

      Read 2026-11-14 from the PubMed record (structured abstract of the version of record).

      Currentness check · 2026-11-14

      No later systematic review comparing residential settings for people with dementia was identified among the results reviewed.

      Method: PubMed search via the PubMed MCP connector for later systematic reviews of the same question.

      Not covered: Only the first results were reviewed.

      Adjacent evidence, not incorporated into this journey: Zimmerman et al., JAMA Netw Open 2022 (PMID 36173637), a Delphi consensus on care in assisted living, states that assisted living is not a health care setting. A clinical reviewer should decide whether it belongs in this journey.

    • Del-Pino-Casado R, Rodríguez Cardosa M, López-Martínez C, et al. The association between subjective caregiver burden and depressive symptoms in carers of older relatives: a systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS One. 2019;14(5):e0217648.

      https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0217648

      Read 2026-11-14 from the PubMed record (structured abstract of the version of record).

      Currentness check · 2026-11-14

      No later meta-analysis of the same association was identified among the results reviewed.

      Method: PubMed search via the PubMed MCP connector for later systematic reviews of the same question.

      Not covered: Only the first results were reviewed.

    • Mertens F, Sercu M, Derycke A, et al. Patients' experiences of transfers between care settings in palliative care: an interview study. Ann Palliat Med. 2022;11(9):2830-2843.

      https://doi.org/10.21037/apm-22-146

      Read 2026-11-14 from the PubMed record (structured abstract of the version of record).

      Currentness check · 2026-11-14

      A primary study is not superseded by later studies; later work adds to it rather than replaces it.

      Method: PubMed record review via the PubMed MCP connector.

      Not covered: Corrections or later reanalyses were not searched for separately.

    • Cohen LW, Zimmerman S, Reed D, et al. Dementia in relation to family caregiver involvement and burden in long-term care. J Appl Gerontol. 2014;33(5):522-540.

      https://doi.org/10.1177/0733464813505701

      Read 2026-11-14 from the PubMed record (structured abstract of the version of record).

      Currentness check · 2026-11-14

      A primary study is not superseded by later studies; later work adds to it rather than replaces it.

      Method: PubMed record review via the PubMed MCP connector.

      Not covered: Corrections or later reanalyses were not searched for separately.

    Each clinical statement above paraphrases one of these sources closely. Filing it under a priority, or reading it against priorities you saved, is a Values in Care editorial operation rather than a source finding.

    Open Source Watch