Values in Care

    Coverage Map

    Values in Care is built to cover the values that shape care at every stage of life, but today's deepest, most verified content is serious illness and end of life. This page states plainly what exists, what's underway, and what's planned next, so the resource's actual scope is never a surprise.

    See how each item gets added in Methodology, review known gaps in Limitations, and inspect every published claim in the evidence index.

    Covered

    In development

    Fasting & Medication (e.g., Ramadan, Yom Kippur)

    In development

    Chronic illness

    Verified evidence so far (5 citations)

    Clinical evidence layer shipped: IDF-DAR fasting guidelines (2017/2021), the 13-country EPIDIAR hypoglycemia study, Ramadan T2D treatment options, and IDF-DAR risk-tool validation. Tradition-authority rulings are drafted but held until directly verified.

    See the evidence gathered so far →

    Blood Products & Transfusion

    In development

    Hospital care

    Verified evidence so far (5 citations)

    Clinical evidence layer shipped: patient blood management meta-analysis, Cleveland Clinic outcomes in Jehovah’s Witness cardiac-surgery patients, Cochrane cell salvage, and EPO/IV-iron blood-conservation evidence. Tradition-authority sources are drafted but held until directly verified.

    See the evidence gathered so far →

    Truth-Telling, Disclosure & Decision-Making Styles

    In development

    Serious illness

    Verified evidence so far (2 citations)

    Evidence lives in the care-frameworks layer: documented ethnicity-level variation in disclosure and decision-making preferences (Blackhall 1995) and the three culturally varying EOL dimensions (Searight 2005). Deliberately kept culture-level — per-tradition rows require tradition-authority sources.

    See the evidence gathered so far →

    Dietary Law in Inpatient Care

    In development

    Hospital care

    Verified evidence so far (10 citations)

    Clinical evidence layer shipped, focused on the under-recognized medication-excipient problem: >1,000 drugs contain animal-derived gelatin, heparin is porcine, source is often unidentifiable from labeling, most patients want disclosure and alternatives (e.g., fondaparinux), and hospital food provision tracks with satisfaction. Tradition-authority rulings on necessity/permissibility are drafted but held until directly verified.

    See the evidence gathered so far →

    Modesty, Gender-Concordant Care & Chaperones

    In development

    Hospital care

    Verified evidence so far (8 citations)

    Clinical evidence layer shipped, and it is deliberately balanced: gender concordance is generally linked to better communication and trust (especially for women on sensitive issues), yet does NOT reliably improve hard outcomes and most patients prioritize competence over concordance. Modesty is a documented barrier to cervical screening for observant women (female clinicians / self-sampling help), and offering chaperones for intimate exams — while respecting the right to decline — is the well-supported norm across patients including gender-diverse populations. Tradition-authority guidance (Islam, Orthodox Judaism) is drafted but held until directly verified.

    See the evidence gathered so far →

    Organ Donation → Transplant Receiving

    In development

    Serious illness

    Verified evidence so far (7 citations)

    Clinical evidence layer shipped, extending the existing donation content to the recipient side: neighborhood segregation predicts unequal access to living-donor liver transplant; living kidney donation carries real but selective donor risk; public acceptance of xenotransplantation (pig organs) is significantly lower when patients perceive religious conflict, and a 916-person survey of Jewish patients found religious-ruling knowledge (not blanket prohibition) shapes attitudes; willingness to receive tissue allografts tracks with religious affiliation; eHealth adherence support for lifelong immunosuppression shows a positive RCT signal that weakens under broader, lower-quality-evidence review. Tradition-authority rulings (Islam, Judaism, Jehovah’s Witnesses) are drafted but held until directly verified.

    See the evidence gathered so far →

    Mental Health & Values

    In development

    Chronic illness

    Verified evidence so far (7 citations)

    Clinical evidence layer shipped, deliberately not one-sided: religious/spiritual engagement is a real but modest and heterogeneous protective factor (small inverse association with PTSD after disaster; spiritual wellbeing protective against youth depression) — but negative religious coping (feeling abandoned by or blamed by God) trends toward worse depression, and religious affiliation is one of several protective factors against suicide mortality. Stigma and religious/cultural beliefs are consistently documented as help-seeking barriers (Saudi Arabia, ASEAN, Arab men in Western countries), yet the same religious dimension also functions as a facilitator via social support — and a WHO/SAMHSA-informed framework (COPE) proposes structured collaboration between mental health services and faith organizations rather than treating them as opposed. Tradition-authority positions (Islam, Catholic, Orthodox Judaism) are drafted but held until directly verified — and notably, they are not uniform: documented Orthodox Jewish caution toward secular psychotherapy differs meaningfully from Islamic and Catholic institutional engagement.

    See the evidence gathered so far →

    Maternal & Reproductive Care Values

    In development

    Chronic illness

    Verified evidence so far (8 citations)

    Clinical evidence layer shipped. Scope note: this topic deliberately excludes abortion — it covers fertility treatment, pregnancy loss, high-risk/life-limiting-diagnosis decision-making, family planning, and postpartum mental health. Documented tradition positions on fertility treatment vary substantially and are not one "religious view" (IVF/IUI opposed by Catholic teaching but not by Hinduism/Buddhism; surrogacy and vasectomy impermissible across several traditions; Islam permits IVF/embryo transfer between spouses only). Religious participation shows a real, quantified protective association with postpartum depression and perinatal anxiety, and Islamic concepts like tawakkul (trust in divine destiny) documentedly ease grief after pregnancy loss — while religious belief is also the single most-cited reason for non-use of family planning services in the largest study reviewed. An official joint clinical-society framework supports palliative, family-centered care for life-limiting fetal diagnoses independent of prognosis certainty.

    See the evidence gathered so far →

    Pediatric Serious Illness & Family Decision-Making

    In development

    Serious illness

    Verified evidence so far (6 citations)

    Clinical evidence layer shipped. A longitudinal qualitative study found religion/spirituality directly influenced parental decision-making in 13 of 16 cases of children with life-threatening conditions — but most clinicians were unaware of this influence, underscoring the "ask, don't assume" principle at the family's most vulnerable moment. National and systematic-review evidence shows clinicians often delay initiating advance care planning due to prognostic uncertainty and unclear responsibility, and identifies concrete roles (including chaplains) that support families through PICU end-of-life decisions. A peer-reviewed Catholic-perspective article on decision-making for critically ill infants is included directly (compiled from primary Catholic teaching); Islamic guardianship/consent-authority guidance is drafted but held until directly verified.

    See the evidence gathered so far →

    Vaccination & Preventive Care Across Traditions

    In development

    Everyday care

    Verified evidence so far (5 citations)

    Clinical evidence layer shipped. Religious leaders play both positive and negative/neutral roles in vaccine acceptance across systematic reviews — trust-building and community dialogue are documented alongside instances of hesitancy reinforcement, so their influence is not uniform in either direction. Religion is one factor among several (alongside mistrust, safety concerns, and access) shaping documented hesitancy, and a review of anthroposophic communities found a broad spectrum of vaccine beliefs rather than uniform refusal, with vaccine-hesitant members facing stigma from both outside and inside the community. On the facilitator side, a randomized trial found a scripture-embedded HPV vaccination message significantly outperformed standard secular messaging among Christian parents of unvaccinated adolescents. Islamic guidance on the istihala (chemical transformation) doctrine, which some scholars apply to permit porcine-derived vaccine ingredients when no alternative exists, is drafted but held until directly verified.

    See the evidence gathered so far →

    Substance Use, Harm Reduction & Values

    In development

    Chronic illness

    Verified evidence so far (7 citations)

    Clinical evidence layer shipped. Spirituality/religion shows at least some documented beneficial association with substance-use recovery outcomes across a systematic review, and a longitudinal study found higher spiritual well-being predicted less frequent substance use in early recovery among predominantly Black/African American adults — though this effect, like a parallel 12-step-involvement effect, diminished within months, an honest limit rather than a durable cure claim. Religious/community leaders in culturally diverse communities are documented playing both barrier and enabler roles in treatment access, and a systematic review of Muslim communities found stigma and trust (not religiosity itself) as the primary access barriers. On harm reduction specifically: community naloxone distribution shows strong survival evidence, while a rigorous meta-analysis found neither abstinence-based nor harm-reduction interventions category holds a clear overall advantage over the other — both are presented without taking a policy position. VA chaplains are documented providing real but under-resourced addiction care. Islamic necessity (darura) principle permitting otherwise-prohibited substances in medical treatment, potentially applicable to addiction pharmacotherapy, is drafted but held until directly verified.

    See the evidence gathered so far →

    Aging, Disability & Caregiving Theologies

    In development

    Chronic illness

    Verified evidence so far (8 citations)

    Clinical evidence layer shipped. Religious/spiritual coping is documented as helping family caregivers manage grief and burden (dementia caregiving, oncology caregiving), and religiosity is a documented correlate of care-dependent older adults' attitudes toward assisted dying. Cultural/religious framings of disability are documented as a genuine source of exclusion in some contexts, but the same qualitative literature also surfaces counter-framings — Ubuntu's ethic of interconnection in Zimbabwe, religious communities named as "welcoming places" by people with serious mental illness — so exclusion is not treated as the whole story. A peer-reviewed Catholic Social Teaching analysis of disability exclusion and pastoral response ships directly at PASS tier. Islamic teaching on the duty to honor and care for aging parents is drafted but held until directly verified.

    See the evidence gathered so far →

    Genetics, Screening & Emerging-Technology Ethics

    In development

    Chronic illness

    Verified evidence so far (8 citations)

    Clinical evidence layer shipped. Scope note: this topic covers genetic counseling, screening, gene editing, and AI-assisted diagnosis themselves — it does not cover selective termination decisions, which fall under the maternal & reproductive care topic's existing abortion exclusion. Religious/spiritual belief functions as a documented coping heuristic for genetic uncertainty, yet genetic-counseling training programs report inconsistent preparation to discuss it. A large U.S. survey across nine religious/non-religious groups found real variation in gene-editing attitudes by group (Muslim participants most concerned, atheists least) but explicitly cautions against generalizing within any group. AI-diagnosis trust surveys in South Africa found religion significantly predicts preferring a human doctor over an AI one. Islamic guidance permitting therapeutic gene editing (not enhancement or lineage-altering uses) is drafted but held until directly verified.

    See the evidence gathered so far →

    Secular / Humanist / Existential Values

    In development

    Everyday care

    Verified evidence so far (7 citations)

    Clinical evidence layer shipped. Not a "13th tradition" bolt-on — this topic exists because values must never implicitly mean religious only. One in four American patients now identify as religiously unaffiliated, and chaplains describe spiritual caregiving as still contributing to holistic wellbeing for patients who are spiritual-but-not-religious, secular humanist, atheist, or agnostic — with assessment tools proposed specifically for this population rather than adapted from religious frameworks. Secular, structured clinical interventions (dignity therapy, meaning-centered psychotherapy) address existential distress without religious counsel. Nonreligious identity is documented as not monolithic (nonreligious-theistic families still sought religious support at their child's death) and the debate over faith-based vs. secular/humanist chaplaincy models is documented on both sides, not resolved. Humanist organizational positions on end-of-life meaning-making and self-determination are drafted but held until directly verified.

    See the evidence gathered so far →

    Planned

    Acute & Emergency Care

    Planned

    Hospital care

    Not yet built: awaiting its own research and verification cycle before publication.

    Pain Management & Opioid Decisions

    Planned

    Serious illness

    Not yet built: awaiting its own research and verification cycle before publication.

    Intensive Care & Family Presence

    Planned

    Hospital care

    Not yet built: awaiting its own research and verification cycle before publication.

    Surgery & Anesthesia

    Planned

    Hospital care

    Not yet built: awaiting its own research and verification cycle before publication.

    Primary & Chronic Illness Care

    Planned

    Chronic illness

    Not yet built: awaiting its own research and verification cycle before publication.

    Infectious Disease & Isolation

    Planned

    Hospital care

    Not yet built: awaiting its own research and verification cycle before publication.

    Rehabilitation & Recovery

    Planned

    Chronic illness

    Not yet built: awaiting its own research and verification cycle before publication.

    Oral Health

    Planned

    Everyday care

    Not yet built: awaiting its own research and verification cycle before publication.

    Migrant & Refugee Health

    Planned

    Everyday care

    Not yet built: awaiting its own research and verification cycle before publication.

    Health Care During Incarceration

    Planned

    Chronic illness

    Not yet built: awaiting its own research and verification cycle before publication.

    Homelessness & Unstable Housing

    Planned

    Everyday care

    Not yet built: awaiting its own research and verification cycle before publication.

    Violence, Abuse & Safeguarding

    Planned

    Everyday care

    Not yet built: awaiting its own research and verification cycle before publication.

    Disaster & Mass-Casualty Care

    Planned

    Hospital care

    Not yet built: awaiting its own research and verification cycle before publication.

    Was this page helpful?