Place a feeding tube
Nutrition and fluids through a tube into the stomach (gastrostomy) or through the nose (nasogastric).
Three of four studies of mixed or unspecified tube feeding found tube feeding associated with longer survival; the fourth, the largest, found no effect. Certainty is very low.
Applies to: Non-randomized studies; 310 participants in the three, 1386 in the fourth.
Two studies gave very-low-certainty evidence that tube feeding improved nutritional measures.
Applies to: Non-randomized studies of adults with severe dementia.
Four studies of gastrostomy (PEG) tubes found no evidence of an effect on survival time (low certainty).
Applies to: 36,816 participants in four non-randomized studies.
Survival did not differ between residents who had a gastrostomy tube placed and those who did not, and placing it sooner after eating problems began did not change survival.
Applies to: 36,492 residents, 1,957 of them tube-fed. US nursing home residents with advanced cognitive impairment from dementia and new problems eating, 1999 to 2007.
Residents who had a gastrostomy tube placed in hospital were 2.27 times as likely to develop a new pressure ulcer, and existing ulcers were less likely to heal.
Applies to: Propensity-matched US nursing home residents with advanced cognitive impairment who recently needed help eating; 1124 with a tube placed for new ulcers, 461 for healing.
On balance, the studies suggested a higher risk of pneumonia with tube feeding, though results were inconsistent.
Applies to: Five non-randomized studies reporting harms.
Tube feeding is associated with agitation, more use of physical and chemical restraints, and health care visits for tube complications.
Applies to: Older adults with advanced dementia, as summarized in the position statement.
In one study, more carers in the tube feeding group reported a very heavy burden. The same study found no difference in pain or comfort.
Applies to: One non-randomized study using mixed tube feeding methods.