CPR or a do-not-resuscitate order

    Whether an older or seriously ill adult wants CPR attempted if their heart stops in hospital, or a do-not-resuscitate (DNR) order.

    Older adults and adults with serious illness, such as advanced cancer, and the people deciding with them. The studies come from the US, Taiwan and Korea, across different years.

    SourcedModeledNo projected outcomes are generated on this page.

    Pending clinical review. Each statement is paraphrased from the named source, but no clinician has reviewed this page yet. Use it to prepare questions, not to choose a treatment.

    What this decision concerns

    In US Medicare data, survival after in-hospital CPR did not improve from 1992 through 2005, while the share of in-hospital deaths preceded by CPR increased.

    SourcedUS Medicare cohort study · 2009

    For people with advanced cancer, the effects of CPR remain to be worked out, so the choice rests on evidence that is incomplete.

    SourcedTaiwan population-based cohort study · 2019

    The options

    Attempt CPR if the heart stops

    Chest compressions, and often a breathing tube and electric shocks, to try to restart the heart.

    • 18.3% of older adults who had CPR in hospital survived to leave the hospital.

      Applies to: 433,985 Medicare beneficiaries aged 65 or older who had CPR in US hospitals, 1992 to 2005.

      SourcedUS Medicare cohort study · 2009

    • Survival after CPR was lower for people who were older, had more other illnesses, or had been admitted from a skilled nursing facility.

      Applies to: 433,985 Medicare beneficiaries aged 65 or older who had CPR in US hospitals, 1992 to 2005.

      SourcedUS Medicare cohort study · 2009

    • Among survivors, the share discharged home rather than to a health care facility fell over the study years.

      Applies to: 433,985 Medicare beneficiaries aged 65 or older who had CPR in US hospitals, 1992 to 2005.

      SourcedUS Medicare cohort study · 2009

    • People who depended on others for daily activities had lower odds of surviving to discharge, whether they came from home (odds ratio 0.76) or a nursing home (0.79).

      Applies to: Inpatients aged 65 or older with cardiac arrest in a North American registry, 2000 to 2008.

      SourcedGet With The Guidelines-Resuscitation registry study · 2013

    • 82.8% of people with stage IV cancer who had CPR in hospital did not survive to discharge. Survivors lived a median of 22 days after leaving.

      Applies to: 3,446 adults with stage IV cancer who had in-hospital CPR in Taiwan, 2009 to 2014.

      SourcedTaiwan population-based cohort study · 2019

    • Survivors had 185 hospital readmissions per 100 people in the first year.

      Applies to: 6,972 US adults aged 65 or older who survived an in-hospital cardiac arrest.

      SourcedGet With The Guidelines-Resuscitation registry study · 2014

    • Rib fractures were found in 62.7% of people who survived CPR for an in-hospital arrest, and in 83.2% after an arrest outside hospital.

      Applies to: 148 adults with successful CPR at one Korean center, scanned with CT.

      SourcedKorean registry study · 2015

    Have a do-not-resuscitate order

    No CPR if the heart stops. Other treatment is decided separately.

    • Having a DNR order on file was linked to lower odds of an intensive care stay (adjusted odds ratio 0.57) and of other intensive measures.

      Applies to: 2,566 adults aged 65 or older who died in two New York City hospitals, 2015 to 2017. An association, not proof of cause.

      SourcedUS hospital cohort study · 2021

    • A DNR order placed later in the stay, or none at all, was linked to more intensive care than a DNR order in place on admission.

      Applies to: 2,566 adults aged 65 or older who died in two New York City hospitals, 2015 to 2017. An association, not proof of cause.

      SourcedUS hospital cohort study · 2021

    • People with do-not-intubate or do-not-resuscitate orders received high-flow oxygen for breathing failure, and it was generally well tolerated.

      Applies to: 293 hospitalized adults with acute respiratory failure in six studies, all at high risk of bias.

      SourcedSystematic review · 2019

    • Family members were less likely to have significant post-traumatic stress symptoms in bereavement when a DNR order had been issued before the death.

      Applies to: 319 family members of patients who died in two Taiwanese ICUs. An association, with a wide confidence interval.

      SourcedTaiwan prospective bereavement study · 2021

    • Hospital death rates among people with these orders who received high-flow oxygen ranged from 40% to 87%.

      Applies to: The same six studies; these patients were already very ill.

      SourcedSystematic review · 2019

    Set against what matters to you

    Modeled

    Read from what you saved on this device.

    What sources report about what matters to you

    Nothing yet. Mark what matters to you, and anything the sources say about it shows up here.

    Pulls in two directions

    Nothing so far pulls against anything else.

    Still unknown

    • Nothing is marked as a priority yet, so nothing here is connected to what matters to you. The options and their sources are still readable below.

      Not in the sources here.

    • Every study of other breathing support with a DNR order was at high risk of bias.

      Systematic review, 2019 statement

    • These figures come from different countries, years and groups of patients. They cannot be set side by side as one estimate, and the Medicare data end in 2005.

      Not in the sources here.

    • What a DNR order covers, and which other treatments continue, differs between hospitals and places. The sources here do not settle it.

      Not in the sources here.

    Worth asking

    • If my heart stopped here, what would CPR involve, and what do you expect it would achieve for someone like me?
    • If I had a DNR order, which other treatments would I still get?
    • Can I change this decision later, and who needs to know?
    • Who would speak for me if I could not, and do they know what I want?
    • What matters most to me if my health gets worse?
    Start with what matters

    How this measures up

    Checked against IPDAS 5.0: 9 met, 2 partly met, 3 not met

    Sets source-backed statements about named options against what the person said matters. Does not meet the development and evaluation standard a patient decision aid requires. Three further stages would be needed to call it a patient decision aid: essential-criteria appraisal, an independent bias appraisal, and an evaluation of what it changes for the people who use it. None has been done. 5 criteria below are not fully met.

    Qualifying criteria

    • MetHealth conditionchecked automatically

      A source-backed description of the health condition or event is recorded separately from the option comparison.

    • MetExplicit decisionchecked automatically

      States the decision: "Whether an older or seriously ill adult wants CPR attempted if their heart stops in hospital, or a do-not-resuscitate (DNR) order."

    • MetTarget audiencechecked automatically

      Names who this is for: "Older adults and adults with serious illness, such as advanced cancer, and the people deciding with them. The studies come from the US, Taiwan and Korea, across different years."

    • Partly metOptionschecked automatically

      2 options, none flagged as the wait-or-decline choice.

    • MetBenefitschecked automatically

      5 recorded statements read as supporting an option.

    • MetHarmschecked automatically

      7 recorded statements read as burdening an option.

    • Not metValues clarificationrecorded judgment

      Not assessed. An unassessed criterion is not a met one.

    Bias reduction

    • Partly metBest available evidencechecked automatically

      8 primary sources cited, each paraphrased closely. Dated currentness checks found no final newer edition of any source. That remains a negative currentness finding rather than proof that no update is underway.

    • Not metUser involvement in developmentrecorded judgment

      No patient, caregiver, or clinician took part in developing this journey. No usability or comprehension testing has been run on it.

    • MetNeutral presentation of optionschecked automatically

      Every option carries at least one statement in each direction, so no option is recorded as all upside or all downside.

    • MetComplete citationschecked automatically

      8 sources, each with a full citation, a resolving identifier, a publication date, and the date and route it was read.

    • MetPublication or version datechecked automatically

      Last reviewed 2026-11-14.

    • Not metUpdate policyrecorded judgment

      Each journey records when it was last reviewed. A recheck cadence and triggers are proposed, and source recheck due dates are computed from them, but no owner has adopted the policy. This stays unmet until one does.

    • MetFunding disclosedrecorded judgment

      Funding and editorial independence are stated at /independence.

    Screening decisions

    • Not applicableWhat the test measureschecked automatically

      This journey is not a screening decision.

    • Not applicableConsequences of a positive resultchecked automatically

      This journey is not a screening decision.

    • Not applicableNext steps after either resultchecked automatically

      This journey is not a screening decision.

    • Not applicableOverdiagnosis and false positiveschecked automatically

      This journey is not a screening decision.

    This checks the seven IPDAS 5.0 qualifying criteria, seven bias-reduction criteria, and four screening-specific criteria against what each journey holds. IPDAS 5.0 contains more than these. A criterion absent here has not been assessed and is not passed. Standard: IPDAS 5.0, published 2026-06-12. Assessment is by Values in Care, not by IPDAS or any outside reviewer.

    Sources

    Sourced
    • Ehlenbach WJ, Barnato AE, Curtis JR, et al. Epidemiologic study of in-hospital cardiopulmonary resuscitation in the elderly. N Engl J Med. 2009;361(1):22-31.

      https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa0810245

      Read 2026-11-14 from the PubMed record (structured abstract of the version of record).

      Currentness check · 2026-11-14

      An observational study is not superseded by later studies; later work adds to it rather than replaces it.

      Method: PubMed record review via the PubMed MCP connector.

      Not covered: Corrections or later reanalyses were not searched for separately.

      Adjacent evidence, not incorporated into this journey: The Medicare data end in 2005. No 2022-or-later systematic review of in-hospital CPR outcomes in older adults was identified; a clinical reviewer should check for newer registry analyses.

    • Abbo ED, Yuen TC, Buhrmester L, et al. Cardiopulmonary resuscitation outcomes in hospitalized community-dwelling individuals and nursing home residents based on activities of daily living. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2013;61(1):34-39.

      https://doi.org/10.1111/jgs.12068

      Read 2026-11-14 from the PubMed record (structured abstract of the version of record).

      Currentness check · 2026-11-14

      An observational study is not superseded by later studies; later work adds to it rather than replaces it.

      Method: PubMed record review via the PubMed MCP connector.

      Not covered: Corrections or later reanalyses were not searched for separately.

    • Lee MR, Yu KL, Kuo HY, et al. Outcome of stage IV cancer patients receiving in-hospital cardiopulmonary resuscitation: a population-based cohort study. Sci Rep. 2019;9(1):9478.

      https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-45977-4

      Read 2026-11-14 from the PubMed record (structured abstract of the version of record).

      Currentness check · 2026-11-14

      An observational study is not superseded by later studies; later work adds to it rather than replaces it.

      Method: PubMed record review via the PubMed MCP connector.

      Not covered: Corrections or later reanalyses were not searched for separately.

      Adjacent evidence, not incorporated into this journey: Kjørstad et al., Tidsskr Nor Laegeforen 2013 (PMID 23423208), a review in advanced cancer, concludes cancer patients had poorer post-CPR survival than others, while this cohort's matched analysis found similar in-hospital mortality. A clinical reviewer should reconcile them.

    • Chan PS, Nallamothu BK, Krumholz HM, et al. Readmission rates and long-term hospital costs among survivors of an in-hospital cardiac arrest. Circ Cardiovasc Qual Outcomes. 2014;7(6):889-895.

      https://doi.org/10.1161/CIRCOUTCOMES.114.000925

      Read 2026-11-14 from the PubMed record (structured abstract of the version of record).

      Currentness check · 2026-11-14

      An observational study is not superseded by later studies; later work adds to it rather than replaces it.

      Method: PubMed record review via the PubMed MCP connector.

      Not covered: Corrections or later reanalyses were not searched for separately.

    • Seung MK, You JS, Lee HS, et al. Comparison of complications secondary to cardiopulmonary resuscitation between out-of-hospital cardiac arrest and in-hospital cardiac arrest. Resuscitation. 2016;98:64-72.

      https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resuscitation.2015.11.004

      Read 2026-11-14 from the PubMed record (structured abstract of the version of record).

      Currentness check · 2026-11-14

      An observational study is not superseded by later studies; later work adds to it rather than replaces it.

      Method: PubMed record review via the PubMed MCP connector.

      Not covered: Corrections or later reanalyses were not searched for separately.

    • Luth EA, Pan CX, Viola M, et al. Dementia and early do-not-resuscitate orders associated with less intensive end-of-life care: a retrospective cohort study. Am J Hosp Palliat Care. 2021;38(12):1417-1425.

      https://doi.org/10.1177/1049909121989020

      Read 2026-11-14 from the PubMed record (structured abstract of the version of record).

      Currentness check · 2026-11-14

      An observational study is not superseded by later studies; later work adds to it rather than replaces it.

      Method: PubMed record review via the PubMed MCP connector.

      Not covered: Corrections or later reanalyses were not searched for separately.

    • Wilson ME, Mittal A, Dobler CC, et al. High-flow nasal cannula oxygen in patients with acute respiratory failure and do-not-intubate or do-not-resuscitate orders: a systematic review. J Hosp Med. 2020;15(2):101-106.

      https://doi.org/10.12788/jhm.3329

      Read 2026-11-14 from the PubMed record (structured abstract of the version of record).

      Currentness check · 2026-11-14

      No later systematic review of the same question was identified among the results reviewed.

      Method: PubMed search via the PubMed MCP connector for later reviews of treatment under do-not-resuscitate or do-not-intubate orders.

      Not covered: Only the first results of each search were reviewed.

    • Tang ST, Huang CC, Hu TH, et al. Course and predictors of posttraumatic stress-related symptoms among family members of deceased ICU patients during the first year of bereavement. Crit Care. 2021;25(1):282.

      https://doi.org/10.1186/s13054-021-03719-x

      Read 2026-11-14 from the PubMed record (structured abstract of the version of record).

      Currentness check · 2026-11-14

      An observational study is not superseded by later studies; later work adds to it rather than replaces it.

      Method: PubMed record review via the PubMed MCP connector.

      Not covered: Corrections or later reanalyses were not searched for separately.

    Each clinical statement above paraphrases one of these sources closely. Filing it under a priority, or reading it against priorities you saved, is a Values in Care editorial operation rather than a source finding.

    Open Source Watch